The train from Chicago to New York (or from New York to Chicago depending on which way you’re going), passes through several towns in northern Ohio that have “railway museums”. There’s an even more extensive one in Utica, NY. Fascinated as I am with all things “transportation”, I used to take delight in such displays (though I’ve never gotten off of the train in either Ohio or Utica to poke around). On reflection, however, I find that “railway museums”, like “aviation museums”, are mainly just collections of old stuff that gets progressively rustier and dustier.
In Wishful Thinking (1975), Frederick Buechner notes that there are two kinds of remembering. The first, which he calls “nostalgia”, is making an excursion from the living present back into the dead past. If I would do that at a railway museum, it wouldn’t mean climbing aboard a caboose or locomotive (I’ve never been on a train crew) but sitting in a coach seat. There’s no thrill in that. At an aviation museum it would be even less exciting. My experience with flying around didn’t begin until I was 18. Except for a few military transport flights I took when a soldier in Vietnam, everything has been on commercial airliners. Not one flight has been worth the effort it would take to remember it.
Buechner’s other way of remembering is to summon the dead past into the living present. He likens this to a widow, dreaming that her deceased husband is with her, and feeling him at her side. He compares it to what happens at Mass in church. When we “do this in remembrance”, we’re not taking a trip down a memory lane that stretches back longer than we’ve been alive. In very present time we are experiencing living communion with something that happened long ago.
Seeing old railway coaches in Utica, I’ve no desire to ride or to have ridden in a single one of them. Old dining cars in Ohio to not evoke memories of meals enjoyed while riding the rails. When current Amtrak equipment is deemed to be no longer usable and gets replaced, I hope all of the current stuff gets scrapped and the pieces get recycled. But… speaking Taiwanese, which used to be how I lived from day to day, brings a past which is no longer operative into my current awareness. Waking in the morning with a fresh memory that “sometime last night” an already forgotten portion of what I dreamed had been in Taiwanese is a great way to start the day.
Later this year I’ll attend the 50th reunion of my high school graduating class. In preparation for being part of the party, I’ll hope to focus on “making something live again” rather than “remembering what it was like.” There’s enough rust and dust in the transportation museums. There was enough sadness in adolescence. I hope not to add to any of those in 67-and-68-year-old crowd I’ll be joining.
David Alexander resides in Holland, MI after 39 years in Taiwan.
